Roger 兴发Ebert.Home

米纳里

Lee Isaac Chung“Minari”从其开放时刻施放了一个咒语,一种类似于人类的令人生畏的唤起,试图与自然世界保持和谐。作为一辆家庭的汽车旅行通过绿色的美国景观,地球本身似乎与这些人物交谈,并通过他们向我们讲述。

It is a classic immigrant story with specific, often unique new details. A Korean American family headed by a father, Jacob (Steven Yeun) and mother Monica (Yeri Han), came from Korea in the 1980s and spent time in California working as chicken sexers, separating baby chicks by gender. Now they have moved with their two American-born children, a serious and mature girl named Anne (Noel Kate Cho) and a six-year-old named David (newcomer Alan S. Kim), hoping to start a 50-acre farm in a small Arkansas town.

Culture clash is the unifying subject here, though not the only one. Chung, who waited to make this autobiographical drama until he had several acclaimed films under his belt, knows exactly the story that he wants to tell and how he wants to tell it. Monica and Jacob fight over their shared goals as a couple and their ambitions for their children. The tension of assimilation versus independence underscores every exchange, whether it’s intimate and private or connected to the larger community that they are tentatively getting to know.

很明显,雅各布已经购买了一些版本的“美国梦”,并像原型的20世纪白人农民一样,与Gimme Cap,简而言之,语音,乳房口袋卷烟组件,以及散货炮队步行。莫妮卡似乎更撕裂,看到他们中的两个是显而易见的,因为她来自一个更高的社会阶层,在城市更舒适。正如故事所在的那样,我们开始怀疑她是否遗憾地首先被搬到美国。即使她是游戏,它也是一条艰难的道路,似乎永远不会变得更容易。

Ordinary rituals become fresh and alive when a different frame is put around them, and this is the case in Chung’s film. The couple talks about whether to get a small farm in a community with a larger Korean American population or stick where they are and tough it out in relative isolation, a conversation many couples might have in a similar situation, here it is with all sorts of secondary challenges. What church do we go to? Should we go to church at all? How forward should we be in trying to make new friends with people who do not share our cultural heritage? These are problems that individuals raised in a monoculture don’t think about often, or at all.

The movie loses tension at certain points, relying a bit too strongly on atmospheric nature shots and a haunting score that seems to be performed on a slightly out-of-tune upright piano, and sometimes punting conflicts down the timeline when the viewer may want a bit more examination of them at that moment. But Chung’s grip as a storyteller remains sure. There is a ring of truth to every moment and conversation. The best of these are imbued with a complexity and contradiction that suggests that there’s more to human interactions than whatever advice we were given as kids. A moment after church when young David is casually racially insulted by a young white boy who then immediately speaks to him as a friend, and invites him over to a sleepover, will ring true to anyone who has been on the receiving end of that type of behavior. Everyone in this movie is still learning the right way to behave, including the adults.

The supporting characters are vividly drawn. The great American character actor Will Patton is superb as an evangelical Christian farmer who praises Jesus every minute and is glimpsed in one scene carrying a big wooden cross on his back as he walks along the country road. (Jacob asks if he wants a ride and he says no, he’s got this.) But the best performance belongs to Yuh-Jung Youn as Soonja, Jacob’s grandmother, who is brought in from the old country to provide advice and childcare help. She is a live wire—a cosmopolitan who always speaks her mind and is at ease with profanity, practical joking, and making moral/ethical decisions that could have major repercussions without consulting Jacob or Monica. (When Monica puts a $100 bill in the church collection plate, presumably to make a big impression during their first visit, grandma deftly removes it.)

当人们按照自己的内部指南针行为时,钟有一个用于捕获这些时刻的诀窍,以可能对外部观察者没有意义。并且不欣赏对人类行为的深刻理解,以及普通物体和情况在我们与角色相关时获得象征性含义的方式是不可能的。这是一个可爱,独特的电影。

12月11日今天开幕,在2021年更广泛的释放前进行有限的释放资格赛。

兴发 - 登录

Matt Zoller Seitz is the Editor at Large of RogerEbert.com, TV critic for New York Magazine and Vulture.com, and a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in criticism.

现在玩

Truth to Power
圣莫德
笼罩
落下
Spoor

电影学分

米纳里movie poster

米纳里(2021)

115 minutes

Cast

Steven Yeun作为雅各布

Han Ye-rias Monica

Youn Yuh-Jungas Soonja

Will Patton作为保罗

斯科特阴霾作为比利

Noel Kate Cho作为安妮

艾伦金作为大卫

埃里克·斯塔基作为Randy Boomer.

伊斯莱昂的月亮as Mrs. Oh

Darryl考克斯as Mr. Harlan

Director

Writer

电影院

编辑

Composer

Latest blog posts

评论

评论支持反驳